Wednesday, December 7, 2011

Pearl Harbor 70




Today is the 70th anniversary of the Pearl Harbor attack.

Not coincidentally, it is also my elder brother's birthday.

Bizarre coincidences aside, whenever the words Pearl Harbor come to mind, I often think of an air attack carried out with maximum surprise and sheer impact. It's easy to imagine planes dropping out of the sky to raise merry hell on an unsuspecting enemy. No wonder Pearl Harbor has become a euphemism for a surprise attack. At the same time, this also brought a war fought on the other side of the planet to a truly global scale.

On the celluloid front, this has spawned countless documentaries and two blockbuster films, the older of which, 1969's Tora Tora! Tora!



is held in high regard ...


...than the romantic shit that was Pearl Harbor by Bruckheimer/Bay.

For years, I became intrigued by the story of the attack and thought of several ways as to how the attack might have turned out, especially alternate-history scenarios based on what went wrong. I was also smiling at how it became the subject of Pop's research paper at the AFP General Staff College 20 years ago, which focused on battle analysis of the attack. To be honest, seeing him back then pore several hours into typing the paper and how he got angry at me playing nearby, disrupting his concentration, now made me more curious about what he wrote. Mental note to have him ask for a copy of the file from GSC? Maybe so. I actually looked at xeroxes of various books he researched about the attack. When he stayed in Hawaii in 2001 and 2004 on strategy courses, he told us that he found the time to visit the Pearl Harbour Naval Base and even went to the Arizona Memorial along with Mom. I definitely want to visit there someday.

In recent years, I've heard quite a deal about the myths behind the attack, particularly those concerning whether US President Franklin Roosevelt knew the Japanese would attack Pearl Harbor and deliberately wanted them to do it. To my surprise, Pop believed some of them too.

Thanks to the wonders of Amazon, Wikipedia, and eBay, I got a chance to buy some books that have stood the test of time as the definite tomes to read about the attack...and I even joked that they would have provided Pop with much more information for his paper had he knew about their existence sooner. I tracked down some books, which in my opinion, are the ones to seek if you really want to read about the attack:
  1. At Dawn We Slept: The Untold Story of Pearl Harbor
  2. Pearl Harbor: the Verdict of History
  3. Pearl Harbor Papers: Inside the Japanese Plans
  4. Pearl Harbor: Final Judgment

The first three are written by Gordon Prange, who actually spent 37 years researching the entire attack and interviewed several of the major participants. Reading At Dawn We Slept alone gave me much more insight about what happened, enough to break all revisionist nonsense. Inside the Japanese Plans used materials from Prange's library to further detail the Japanese side of the attack, and were written by scholars Donald Goldstein and Katherine Dillon, who were once Prange's understudies. I'm still missing the fourth book, December 7 1941: The Day The Japanese Attacked Pearl Harbor, also written by the three.

Final Judgment, by Henry Clausen, contains new information about the attack using material from the US military's Magic ciphers, which were finally declassified decades after. It detailed much of the US' failures in interpreting the signals traffic from Japan that had been brewing for months but were never acted upon. I tell you, the book turned my understanding in a whole new direction, especially since the information in the book was finally revealed for the first time. I snapped up a copy of it at a Booksale branch the first time I saw it ... and later found myself saying "Oh shit..." upon reading new revelations several times. I learned that the intelligence failure at Pearl Harbor eventually resulted in the creation of the National Security Agency, which came out of Clausen's testimony during the Pearl Harbor hearings in Congress in late 1945.

In closing, Pearl Harbor was definitely the day of infamy in an earlier age, but to tell you the truth, had the Japanese successfully encoded and delivered the 14-part message that their peace talks with the US were at an end within an hour before the attacks, the general impact on the public might have been lessened. Given the planning and preparations Japan put into the attack, things had the potential to turn many ways that are now the realm of alternate history. On the other hand, the apocryphal quote attributed to Adm Isoroku Yamamoto:
I fear all we have done is to awaken a sleeping giant and fill him with a terrible resolve.

...seemed apt in the sense that it finally brought out the full industrial might of the US, bolstered from years of work thanks to FDR's New Deal.

Despite the horrors of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Japan and the US are close allies. I remember the late Edward Mulhare's closing words in the Pearl Harbour episode of the ABC documentary series Secrets and Mysteries, which I'll quote to wrap up:
That Sunday ignited the last global war, fought to an uneasy peace. We will not be so lucky again.

No comments: